The 5 Best Seafood Places Around Wheeling

The Ohio Valley's best seafood spots range from historic local markets to classic American grills. These five establishments are celebrated by local readers for serving up high-quality fish, shrimp, and shellfish, making them the top choices for satisfying your seafood cravings. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 highlights these essential dining destinations.

Colemans Fish Market

A true local legend since 1914, Colemans is synonymous with the region's best seafood. While instantly famous for its massive Giant Fried Fish Sandwich (often featuring Canadian white fish), Colemans also offers a market selection of fresh fish to take home, alongside items like shrimp sandwiches and deviled crab. Its legacy is built on simple, quality seafood served quickly, making it a historic and indispensable stop for any seafood lover.

Abbey's Restaurant & Lounge

Abbey's is known for its diverse menu, which excels in both Italian-American comfort food and surprisingly extensive seafood offerings. Beyond their award-winning ribs and steak, Abbey's features an array of fish, pasta, and appetizers including Broiled or Fried Canadian White Fish, Norwegian Salmon, Jumbo Fried Shrimp, and the indulgent Whole Blue Mussels with Linguine. For a unique steak-and-seafood experience, try their NY Strip Steak stuffed with fresh herbs and Gulf Shrimp.

Red Lobster

As a national favorite, Red Lobster provides a reliable and diverse menu that brings classic seafood specialties to the Saint Clairsville area. Known for its famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits, the restaurant's menu highlights include the Ultimate Feast (featuring Maine lobster tail, snow crab, and shrimp), various Seafood Boils, and perfectly prepared Atlantic Salmon. Red Lobster is the go-to choice for a comprehensive selection of lobster, crab, and shrimp in a casual setting.

LongHorn Steakhouse in Tridelphia

While renowned for its steaks, LongHorn Steakhouse earns its place among the best seafood spots by offering high-quality, signature fish and shellfish dishes. The standout is the LongHorn Salmon, a hand-cut, fresh Atlantic salmon fillet marinated in a housemade bourbon marinade. Other popular options include Redrock Grilled Shrimp, a crispy Wild West Shrimp appetizer, and the option to add a Lobster Tail to any steak entrée, providing premium surf-and-turf combinations.

Uncle Pete's Restaurant

Uncle Pete's is a beloved American establishment known for its comfort food and generous portions, including highly-rated seafood options. Their Fish Sandwich and Canadian whitefish are particularly popular, often praised for being flavorful, well-prepared, and incredibly tender. Situated by the riverside, Uncle Pete's offers hearty plates and a relaxed atmosphere, ensuring a satisfying and affordable seafood dining experience.

Thanks, Gemini.