The 5 Best Sandwich Places Around Wheeling

A great sandwich is more than just bread and fillings—it's a perfect blend of texture, flavor, and freshness. These five dining spots are celebrated by local readers for serving up the most satisfying and popular sandwiches in the Ohio Valley. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 highlights these essential stops for sandwich lovers.

Colemans Fish Market

Colemans Fish Market is an absolute institution, and their legendary offering is a sandwich that defines the region: the Giant Fish Sandwich. Known for its massive, fresh-caught piece of flaky white fish, perfectly battered and fried, this sandwich is a must-try. Customers praise the quality of the seafood and the sheer size, making it a hearty, iconic, and truly regional meal that draws crowds daily.

The Cheese Melt Grill & Bar

As their name suggests, The Cheese Melt Grill & Bar specializes in elevating the classic grilled cheese into an art form. They are celebrated for their creative combinations, featuring multiple cheeses, gourmet ingredients, and perfect crispy bread. Patrons choose them for indulgent comfort food and inventive sandwiches that go far beyond the basics, offering a diverse and delicious menu centered around melted goodness.

Later Alligator

Later Alligator is a downtown Wheeling favorite known for its eclectic menu, bohemian atmosphere, and gourmet sandwich creations. They excel at providing a unique dining experience, featuring high-quality ingredients and often offering vegetarian and specialty options. Their sandwiches are celebrated for being fresh, creative, and generously sized, making them a top spot for lunch or a casual evening meal.

Izzy's Food Truck & Catering LLC

Izzy's Food Truck & Catering brings a specialized and ever-changing menu of delicious sandwiches and other portable cuisine to the region. As a food truck, their success is built on offering unique, high-impact flavors and quick, friendly service. They are praised for their creativity, quality meats, and the delicious convenience of grabbing a hot, gourmet sandwich on the go.

Uncle Pete's Restaurant

Uncle Pete's Restaurant is a beloved local establishment that excels at classic American comfort food, and their large, satisfying sandwiches are a key reason for their popularity. They are highly regarded for staples like their open-faced sandwiches and the classic, piled-high Reuben. Customers rely on Uncle Pete's for hearty portions, consistency, and the warmth of a traditional, home-style meal.

Thanks, Gemini.