The 5 Best Restaurants Overall Around Wheeling

The Ohio Valley dining scene is rich with local gems, offering everything from classic comfort food to sophisticated fine dining. These five restaurants have earned the highest praise from local diners for their consistency, quality, atmosphere, and service, setting the standard for culinary excellence in the region. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 celebrates these top dining destinations.

Tlaquepaque Mexican Grill & Restaurant

Tlaquepaque in St. Clairsville, OH, rises above the "Best Mexican" category to claim a spot among the overall best restaurants, thanks to its consistent quality, lively atmosphere, and broad menu appeal. It's a favorite for its generous portions of classic Mexican-American cuisine, making it an excellent choice for a vibrant, satisfying, and reliably delicious meal for all ages.

Abbey's Restaurant & Lounge

Abbey's Restaurant & Lounge is a highly respected Wheeling establishment, known for its upscale American and Italian cuisine and its refined yet relaxed atmosphere. Their reputation is built on serving high-quality steaks, seafood, and pasta dishes, making it a go-to choice for celebrations, date nights, or any occasion that calls for exceptional food and dedicated service in a comfortable setting.

Uncle Pete's Restaurant

Uncle Pete's is celebrated as a classic, community-focused diner that has perfected the art of comfort food. This restaurant is recognized for its hearty portions, affordable prices, and friendly, quick service, specializing in breakfast, lunch, and dinner favorites. Its charm lies in its no-frills dedication to serving up delicious, dependable homestyle meals that keep locals coming back year after year.

Later Alligator

Later Alligator stands out as a unique and charming spot, often praised for its eclectic menu, vintage atmosphere, and specialty coffee and beverage selection. Located in Downtown Wheeling, it’s a favorite for lunch, dinner, and dessert, offering creative soups, sandwiches, and, most famously, crepes (both savory and sweet) in a cozy, artsy setting.

The Rose Garden

The Rose Garden is consistently recognized for its refined dining experience and elegant setting, making it ideal for special occasions. They are known for serving modern American and continental dishes with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and impeccable presentation. Located in the beautiful Wheeling Park area, it offers a sophisticated meal with a scenic view.

Thanks, Gemini.