The 5 Best Restaurants for Value Around Wheeling

The Ohio Valley dining scene proves that high quality and large portions don't have to come with a high price tag. The "Best Value" category is a tribute to those essential local establishments that consistently deliver delicious, satisfying meals that stretch your dollar, perfect for families, busy workers, or anyone who appreciates home-style cooking at its best. These five winners, recognized by the Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025, are the places the community trusts for a fantastic meal and a full wallet.

Mehlman Cafeteria

Located at 51800 National E Rd in Saint Clairsville, OH, Mehlman Cafeteria is an institution beloved for its classic, homestyle dining experience. It earns its value award by offering an enormous selection of comfort foods—from meats and potatoes to daily specials and extensive dessert options—all served in generous portions cafeteria-style. Diners appreciate the consistent quality and the ability to build a hearty, personalized meal without spending a fortune.

Bob's Lunch

A true local gem, Bob's Lunch is situated at 800 Third St in Moundsville, WV, and is the definition of a dependable, no-frills eatery. This spot is recognized for its incredible value, specializing in fast, affordable, and filling breakfast and lunch classics. Bob's is a favorite among locals for its friendly atmosphere and the assurance that you can always grab a quick, quality meal—like their famous hot dogs or sandwiches—that tastes great and offers unmatched bang for your buck.

Tlaquepaque Mexican Grill & Restaurant

For those craving vibrant flavors and overflowing plates, Tlaquepaque Mexican Grill & Restaurant in St Clairsville, OH (50601 Valley Plaza Dr), is the top choice for value. Mexican cuisine inherently offers great pricing, but Tlaquepaque stands out for its massive portions, excellent lunch specials, and consistently fresh ingredients. Readers flock here knowing they will receive a huge, delicious meal for a price that encourages frequent visits.

Izzy's Food Truck & Catering LLC

Representing the mobile and dynamic side of the local culinary scene, Izzy's Food Truck & Catering LLC (4109 Irish ridge road, Cameron, WV) brings high-quality, specialty fare directly to the community while keeping prices low. Food trucks often offer superior value by reducing overhead, and Izzy's is celebrated for providing delicious, gourmet-level food at convenient, everyday prices. This recognition highlights their impact in delivering unique and tasty options that offer great mileage for your money.

Little Annie's Sweets

Proving that value extends to dessert, Little Annie's Sweets is a beloved stop at 105 W Market St in Belmont, OH. While focused on sweet treats, their recognition as a best value spot speaks to the generosity of their portions, the high quality of their ingredients, and their approachable pricing. Whether it's a specialty cake, cookies, or a simple baked item, customers feel they get exceptional craftsmanship and flavor for every dollar spent.

Thanks, Gemini.