The 5 Best Real Estate Agents Around Wheeling

A top real estate agent is essential for navigating the local housing market, offering expert guidance whether you are buying or selling. These five individuals are recognized by local readers for their exceptional performance, dedication to clients, and success in the competitive Wheeling area. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 celebrates these premier agents.

David Robbins - Allied Realty Groups

As a top agent at Allied Realty Groups, David Robbins is highly praised for his deep market knowledge and client-focused approach, particularly serving the Moundsville area. He is celebrated for his professionalism, negotiation skills, and ability to successfully guide clients through complex transactions, making him a trusted name in Marshall County real estate.

Kelsey Cromar - RE/MAX Broadwater

Kelsey Cromar is a top-performing agent for RE/MAX Broadwater, leveraging the firm's global resources to benefit her local clients. Her recognition is a testament to her energy, commitment, and mastery of modern real estate technology, which she uses to market properties effectively and find the perfect homes for buyers in the Wheeling region.

Taylor Baugh-McIntire - REALTOR RE/MAX Broadwater

Also with RE/MAX Broadwater, Taylor Baugh-McIntire is celebrated for her dedication to the Ohio Valley market. As a top REALTOR, she is known for her personalized service and local insights, ensuring clients receive attentive care and expert advice throughout the entire buying or selling process.

Jayla Robinson - Charmed Realty

Jayla Robinson of Charmed Realty is recognized as a rising star in the Wheeling real estate community. Her success at a newer local firm highlights her fresh perspective and innovative strategies for listing and selling properties. She is valued for her commitment to providing a smooth and positive real estate experience.

Rebecca Knollinger Castilow - REALTOR RE/MAX Broadwater

Completing the strong representation from RE/MAX Broadwater, Rebecca Knollinger Castilow is another highly-rated REALTOR. Her long-standing recognition in the Readers' Choice awards speaks to her consistent, high-level performance and strong client trust. She is valued for her reliability and extensive experience across all facets of the Wheeling housing market.

Thanks, Gemini.