The 5 Best Places for Pie Around Wheeling

Nothing says comfort like a perfect slice of pie, whether it's a creamy classic or a seasonal fruit masterpiece. The Ohio Valley's best bakers and restaurants are celebrated for their flaky crusts and delicious, high-quality fillings. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 highlights these five premier destinations for pie lovers.

Mehlman Cafeteria

Mehlman Cafeteria is a long-standing institution known for its commitment to classic, comforting American cuisine, with their pies being the jewel in their crown. Customers flock here for the variety of traditional fruit and cream pies, recognizing them for their generous slices, high-quality ingredients, and a consistently perfect, homemade taste. This is the definition of classic comfort pie.

Bob's Lunch

Bob's Lunch in Moundsville, WV, is the beloved local diner that has perfected the art of the freshly baked, homestyle pie. Their inclusion on this list is a testament to their simple, delicious approach, often featuring the day's special flavors displayed right at the counter. They are the go-to spot for that small-town diner charm and a truly satisfying, classic slice.

Fat Apple Bakery

Fat Apple Bakery in Bridgeport, OH, specializes in hand-crafted baked goods, where pie is often the star. They are celebrated for their attention to detail, use of seasonal ingredients, and creative takes on traditional recipes. For those looking for a whole pie for a holiday or celebration, or an indulgent, fresh-baked slice, the Fat Apple offers artisanal quality.

Perkins American Food Co. in Wheeling

Perkins is a well-known name nationwide, but their Wheeling location has earned its spot through the consistent delivery of their signature pie menu. Customers know they can rely on Perkins for a huge selection of classic cream, meringue, and fruit pies available seven days a week. Their popularity is rooted in their reliable quality and broad, always-available variety.

Sweet Abe's Bakeshop

Sweet Abe's Bakeshop is a celebrated newcomer or recent favorite, focusing on a boutique selection of high-quality baked items, including specialty pies. Their recognition highlights a commitment to modern flavors and beautiful presentation. This is the place to find a unique, gourmet pie that adds a touch of elegance to any dessert table.

Thanks, Gemini.