The 5 Best Pizza Places Around Wheeling

From thin-crust classics to gourmet wood-fired creations, the Wheeling area is home to some truly outstanding pizzerias. These five establishments have earned the loyalty of local diners for their perfect crusts, quality toppings, and commitment to the art of the perfect pie. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 celebrates these premier pizza destinations.

Patsy’s Pizza - Elm Grove

Patsy's Pizza is a cherished local favorite, recognized for delivering a classic, satisfying pizza experience. They are celebrated for their consistent quality, generous toppings, and traditional style of crust. For those in the Elm Grove area and beyond, Patsy's is the reliable, go-to spot for a delicious, comforting pizza that perfectly hits the spot.

Fabio's Pizza

Fabio's Pizza, located on Main Street in Wheeling, is known for its dedication to high-quality, fresh ingredients and providing an excellent value. Their strong local following highlights their expertise in crafting pizzas that are both flavorful and generously topped, making them a top choice for a dependable and delicious meal, whether dining in or carrying out.

The Wood Fired Pizza Co.

The Wood Fired Pizza Co. offers a gourmet pizza experience that elevates the classic dish. They specialize in pizzas cooked rapidly at high temperatures in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a distinctively charred crust, smoky flavor, and fresh, bright toppings. This is the must-visit spot for those seeking an authentic, artisan-style Neapolitan or thin-crust pizza.

DeFelice Bros. Pizza (Multiple Locations)

DeFelice Bros. Pizza is a widely recognized regional chain that has earned a spot for its consistent brand quality and broad accessibility throughout the Wheeling area. They are known for offering a diverse menu with signature crust options and unique topping combinations, making them a favorite choice for large orders, sporting events, and reliable delivery.

Zontini's Pizza

Zontini's Pizza in Martins Ferry, OH, is celebrated as a long-time local institution known for its unique take on the traditional pizza. Their popularity suggests they have perfected a certain regional style—perhaps a thick, hearty crust or a unique cheese blend—that keeps customers coming back. Zontini's provides that beloved, local pizza flavor that defines the Ohio Valley.

Thanks, Gemini.