The 5 Best Jewelry Stores Around Wheeling

Whether you're celebrating a major milestone with a dazzling engagement ring, investing in an heirloom piece, or simply looking for the perfect accessory to complete your look, finding a trusted jeweler is essential. The Ohio Valley offers a mix of traditional fine jewelry stores, specialized boutiques, and national leaders. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 recognizes these five top destinations for their craftsmanship, quality inventory, and excellent customer service.

River Valley Designs

River Valley Designs is a modern boutique that has quickly become the local trendsetter, specializing in a blend of ready-to-wear jewelry and experiential services. They are an industry leader in the area's popular Permanent Jewelry trend (delicate, clasp-free welded bracelets), along with offering a Charm Bar for custom piece creation. This focus on unique, interactive shopping experiences and handmade heirlooms makes them the perfect spot for personalized gifts and modern accessories.

16th Street Clay Company

16th Street Clay Company offers a refreshing alternative to traditional fine jewelry, specializing in unique, handmade polymer clay jewelry and miscellaneous metal pieces. Recognized for their distinct artistic style, their offerings often include fun, festive, and seasonal earrings and accessories. This is the ideal spot for shoppers looking for lightweight, artisanal pieces that make a vibrant statement and support a local craftsperson.

Leva's Jewelry Store

Leva's Jewelry Store is a respected, long-standing fine jewelry provider in the Ohio Valley. They specialize in diamonds, gold, estate pieces, and custom-designed jewelry, built on a foundation of over 35 years of passion and integrity. Customers choose Leva's for major purchases like engagement rings and wedding bands, relying on their expertise in quality gemstones and their ability to hand-craft truly unique pieces that become cherished family heirlooms.

KAY Jewelers in St. Clairsville

KAY Jewelers, located in the Ohio Valley Mall area, provides the advantage of a nationally recognized brand known for its extensive selection and reliable financing options. They are a go-to source for classic, mass-market jewelry, including diamond engagement rings, necklaces, watches, and popular branded collections. Customers benefit from the convenience, standardized guarantees, and wide inventory of a major retailer.

Nini's Treasures

Nini's Treasures is recognized as a unique boutique that offers a selection of jewelry alongside other curated gifts and accessories. They are an authorized retailer for several popular brands, most notably Pandora Jewelry and eNewton Jewelry. This means customers can easily find the latest charms, bracelets, and on-trend beaded jewelry from these popular collections, making it a great destination for gifts, self-purchases, and completing fashionable outfits.

Thanks, Gemini.