The 5 Best Italian Restaurants Around Wheeling

Nothing says comfort and celebration like a plate of perfectly sauced pasta, a crisp, brick-oven pizza, or a hearty Italian specialty passed down through generations. The Ohio Valley is rich in Italian-American heritage, and these five restaurants have mastered the art of cucina italiana, earning the unwavering approval of local diners. Whether you crave a classic family recipe or a modern gourmet pie, the Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 recognizes these places as the absolute best for an authentic, unforgettable Italian meal!

Figaretti's Restaurant

Figaretti's has been a Wheeling tradition since 1948, serving up truly authentic, family-owned Italian cuisine. This is the place for those who love tradition. They are most famous for their award-winning, cherished secret family recipe spaghetti sauce and their huge, hearty portions of classics like Fig's Heaping Lasagna and Handmade Potato Gnocchi. Beyond the pasta, they offer fine dining options like specialty ravioli (including Lobster and Wild Mushroom) and Black Angus steaks, all served in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

Fabio’s Pizza

When Italian means pizza, Fabio's is the top choice! They stand out for offering a dizzying variety of specialty pizza styles, including Chicago Style (Thick Round), Napolitana Style (Thin Crust), and Sicilian Style (Thick Square). This isn't your average pizza joint—it's a destination for gourmet pies like the Taco Chicago Style or the Veggie Supreme. If you're looking for deep, complex pizza flavor and unique crust options for the whole family, Fabio's delivers.

Undo's Family Restaurant & Catering

Undo's is synonymous with classic, generous Italian-American dining and versatile catering. Their menu is loaded with comfort food favorites like the Taste of Italy (a combo of Chicken Parmigiana, Baked Rigatoni, and a Jumbo Homemade Meatball) and their signature Undo's Chicken (lightly breaded medallions topped with prosciutto). If you have a large family or are planning an event, Undo's reputation for quality, crowd-pleasing entrees and extensive catering services makes them the reliable choice.

Abbey's Restaurant & Lounge

Abbey's offers a distinctive dining experience, combining a cozy restaurant setting with a vibrant lounge atmosphere. While they offer a wide menu, their inclusion on this list suggests a local favorite for Italian staples and a great night out. They are known for providing both classic Italian entrees and comfortable space for relaxing with drinks, making it the perfect spot for a date night or a casual dinner where you can unwind.

Naples Spaghetti House

Naples is a beloved Steubenville staple, celebrated for its authentic Italian tradition and incredibly generous portions. Diners rave about the rich, homemade sauces and are often delighted by their specialties like delicate Cheese Ravioli, Veal Guisseppi (veal sautéed in sherry wine and topped with shrimp and cheese), and their famous Spaghetti served with fresh, soft French bread. If you want a taste of old-school Italian charm with a guarantee of leaving full and satisfied, this is the place to be.

Thanks, Gemini.