The 5 Best Insurance Agencies Around Wheeling

Choosing the right insurance is a crucial decision that safeguards your home, assets, and future financial well-being. The best agencies offer not just policies, but personalized guidance, competitive rates, and reliable service when you need it most. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 recognizes these five top insurance agencies, highlighting their dedication to serving the community with expertise across a variety of coverage needs.

Paree Insurance Centers

Paree Insurance Centers is an independent insurance agency that offers a significant benefit: they can shop multiple carriers to find the best blend of coverage and pricing for their clients. This allows them to provide comprehensive options for home, auto, life, and business insurance. Their commitment to being an independent resource ensures customers receive objective advice and personalized policy recommendations tailored to their specific risk profile.

Lorri Grisell State Farm Insurance Agency

Lorri Grisell's State Farm agency provides the benefit of being backed by one of the largest and most recognizable insurance companies in the nation. Clients benefit from State Farm's financial strength and robust product line, which includes a wide range of popular auto, home, life, and health insurance options. The agency itself offers personalized, local customer service, combining a national safety net with the trust of a neighborhood agent.

Valleywide Insurance

Valleywide Insurance offers the key benefit of specializing in a broad, valley-centric service area, ensuring a deep understanding of local insurance needs, risks, and regional pricing. As an agency, they likely provide various policy types, including personal and commercial coverage. Their recognition confirms their ability to provide comprehensive policies and reliable claims support to individuals and businesses across the Ohio Valley.

Carnes Insurance Agency, Inc

Carnes Insurance Agency, Inc. is a local, full-service independent agency known for its longevity and commitment to professional service. The benefit of working with Carnes is their expertise across diverse lines of coverage, from complex commercial policies to personal insurance (home, auto, life). Their deep roots in the Bridgeport community suggest a focus on long-term client relationships and highly personalized risk management solutions.

Nationwide Insurance: Fahey-Leavitt Insurance Agency Inc

Fahey-Leavitt Insurance Agency offers the significant advantage of representing the Nationwide brand, which is renowned for its excellent claims service and diverse product portfolio. Furthermore, as part of the Leavitt Group, they have access to extensive resources and expertise, particularly in commercial and specialized insurance markets. This combination provides clients with the stability of a national carrier and the detailed attention of a large, experienced regional agency.

Thanks, Gemini.