The 5 Best Consignment Shops Around Wheeling

Savvy shoppers and sustainability enthusiasts have chosen their favorite spots for quality pre-owned goods. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 recognizes these five consignment and resale shops for their great inventory, fair pricing, and commitment to giving items a second life.

REStyle Wheeling

REStyle Wheeling is a fashion-forward consignment boutique known for offering high-quality, gently used apparel and accessories for women. The shop's mission is centered on sustainable style, providing a curated collection that often includes designer labels and contemporary trends. Patrons appreciate the organized, boutique atmosphere that makes browsing for unique clothing, shoes, and jewelry a comfortable and rewarding experience.

Once Upon A Child The Highlands

Once Upon A Child specializes in reselling gently used items for children, from infants to tweens. They are highly popular among parents for offering a cost-effective way to manage the fast turnover of children's needs. The store actively buys items daily from customers and offers a large selection of clothing, toys, shoes, baby gear, and furniture, ensuring all products meet current safety standards and are in excellent condition.

Payton's Pretties

Payton's Pretties is a respected consignment shop that focuses on providing a diverse selection of clothing and accessories, catering primarily to women's apparel. Located in a high-traffic area, the shop is known for its constantly rotating inventory, offering unique finds and quality brands at competitive prices. Local shoppers rely on Payton's Pretties for affordable, fashionable pieces and a friendly, localized shopping experience.

Bird's Nest

The Bird's Nest is a well-regarded local resale shop known for its eclectic and varied inventory. While they often carry a mix of items, their recognition in the consignment category points to a strong offering of furniture, home décor, and unique household goods. Customers enjoy searching for antique treasures, vintage finds, and gently used, quality items that add character to their homes, all within a welcoming neighborhood environment.

Play It Again Sports

Play It Again Sports is a unique consignment and resale store specializing in new and gently used sporting goods and fitness equipment. They allow customers to buy, sell, and trade used gear, making sports more accessible and affordable for families and athletes. The store offers equipment for a wide range of activities, including baseball, golf, fitness, winter sports, and team sports, providing an economical way to upgrade or start a new athletic hobby.

Thanks, Gemini.