The 5 Best Catering Companies Around Wheeling

From weddings and corporate luncheons to large family gatherings, exceptional catering can make or break an event. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 recognizes these five companies for their culinary expertise, professional service, and ability to deliver customized dining experiences across the Wheeling area.

Carrie's Catering

Carrie's Catering, a personalized service based in Wheeling, is known for its focus on Cajun and Southern comfort food with a Caribbean influence. They specialize in creating memorable dining experiences for all events, including weddings, corporate meetings, and parties. The menu is highly customizable, and they offer a variety of setups, from classic buffet-style to plated and served food stations, all delivered by a professional and friendly staff committed to high-quality flavor and service.

Izzy’s Food Truck And Catering

Izzy’s Food Truck and Catering offers a modern, versatile, and high-quality culinary experience that can be brought directly to the customer's event. Owned and operated by a culinary arts graduate, they specialize in both casual food truck fare (like gourmet smash burgers and wraps) and high-end catering options for formal events, including dishes like Prime Rib and Pork Tenderloin. Their catering services are known for their quality, bold flavors, and a commitment to serving some of the best food in the valley, often highlighted by their renowned cheesecake desserts.

Undo's Family Restaurant & Catering

Undo's Family Restaurant & Catering leverages its strong reputation as a beloved local restaurant to provide extensive catering services, often specializing in Italian-American cuisine. They offer a wide array of options for large and small gatherings, including large tray catering featuring pasta specialties, antipasto, cocktail meatballs, and baked possibilities like lasagna and manicotti. Their ability to manage high-volume requests and their focus on traditional, satisfying Italian flavors make them a trusted name for event organizers.

Hall Of Fame Cafe

Hall Of Fame Cafe, known for its friendly, welcoming atmosphere and hearty dishes, extends its culinary competence to comprehensive catering services. They offer diverse catering menu options suitable for various events, including buffets featuring burgers, chicken, and classic American sides, as well as light lunch options. Their service is flexible, providing food for different event sizes and needs, ensuring great food with a welcoming touch for all catered gatherings.

Table 304

Table 304 provides a unique and artisanal catering focus, specializing in beautifully crafted grazing tables, boards, and boxes along with coffee shop services. They are committed to "Gathering food to create community and conversation," offering specialty items like large trays full of cured meats, cheeses, fruits, and their homemade Jarlsberg cheese spread. Their "Party Bundle" offers a convenient way to feed larger groups with assorted sliders, fresh vegetable trays, and charcuterie, all presented with aesthetic flair.

Thanks, Gemini.