The 5 Best Burgers Around Wheeling

The burger is a true American classic, and the Best of the Ohio Valley Reader's Choice 2025 recognizes the establishments that elevate this staple to an art form. From gourmet creations to classic smash-style patties, these five spots serve up the region's best.

Avenue Eats At Waterfront Hall

Avenue Eats is celebrated for its inventive, award-winning gourmet burgers served in the dynamic atmosphere of the revitalized Waterfront Hall. The menu features a wide array of imaginative options, including the Smoked Gouda Burger with caramelized onion and garlic aioli, the decadent Poutine Burger topped with cheese curds, fries, and brown gravy, and the adventurous Brie and Pear Burger. Avenue Eats consistently pushes the boundaries of the traditional burger, appealing to those looking for a truly unique patty experience.

Bubba's Gourmet Burghers & Beer

Bubba's Gourmet Burghers & Beer lives up to its name by specializing in large, juicy "burghers" and a rotating selection of craft beers. Their signature offering is the Bubba Burgher, a half-pound patty often loaded with cheese and thick-cut bacon. Other fan favorites include the N'awlins Burgher crusted in Cajun spices, and the massive Hunger Buster, which features two gourmet patties layered between two grilled cheese sandwiches, demonstrating a commitment to hearty, indulgent creations.

Izzy's Food Truck & Catering LLC

Izzy's Food Truck is known for its constantly evolving menu of high-quality, creative smash burgers and mobile culinary excellence. Chef Josey Stern, a culinary arts graduate, uses fresh beef to craft unique specialties like the "Gouda Vibes Only" Burger with smoked gouda and bacon jam, and the "Red, White, and Blueberry" Burger featuring house-made blueberry preserves. Their inventive toppings and commitment to quality ingredients make them a destination for burger enthusiasts seeking a gourmet food truck experience.

The Cheese Melt Grill & Bar

The Cheese Melt Grill & Bar, while primarily known for its grilled sandwiches and diner classics (similar to other mentions, the search provided limited direct information for a specific "The Cheese Melt Grill & Bar" in Warwood, Wheeling, but listed a Rose Garden which is a different winner), their inclusion suggests they are a top local spot for a dependable, satisfying burger. Their menu is likely built around comfort food, including various Patty Melts and traditional cheeseburgers, served in a casual grill setting perfect for lunch or dinner.

The Rose Garden

The Rose Garden offers a diverse menu that includes a dedicated section of hand-pattied burgers alongside its popular dinners and broasted chicken. They are known for providing both classic and unique burger options. Favorites include the Texas Smokehouse Burger, a 10-oz patty topped with cheddar, bacon, and onion rings smothered in BBQ sauce, and the local specialty, The Brooklyn, which combines a cheeseburger with corned beef and Swiss cheese on grilled rye bread, catering to a wide range of tastes.

Thanks, Gemini.