The 5 Best BBQs Places Around Wheeling

The smoke is rising over the Ohio Valley as readers have selected their top destinations for authentic barbecue. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 highlights a mix of dedicated roadside smokehouses, full-service restaurants, and mobile caterers known for their expertly smoked meats and signature sauces.

Mason Dixon Barbecue Co.

Mason Dixon Barbecue Co. is a beloved local gem, founded by a combat veteran, that has carved out a loyal following for its commitment to Texas-style barbecue. They smoke their meats low and slow over West Virginia white oak, with favorites including their succulent pulled pork and tender beef brisket. The menu also features unique creations like the Brisket Quesadilla and their homemade Mason Dixon barbecue sauce, providing a hearty, savory experience for every patron.

Dee Jay's BBQ Ribs & Grille

Dee Jay's BBQ Ribs & Grille has been serving the region for over four decades and is renowned for its "Legendary Ribs." The restaurant offers a full dining experience focused on American and BBQ specialties, with its signature baby back ribs available in various sizes, all brushed with Dee Jay's Original Rib BBQ sauce. Beyond ribs, their menu features combos with pulled pork and grilled BBQ chicken, along with a tempting array of house-made sides and desserts.

Hangover BBQ

Hangover BBQ operates as a dedicated roadside carryout smokehouse, specializing in genuine live smoke BBQ cooked low and slow on a custom-made offset smoker. Run by a passionate husband and wife team, they focus on dry-rub only for their meats, allowing the flavor of the smoke and premium cuts to shine, with homemade sauces available on the side. This spot is popular for its high-quality, craft barbecue and Southern cuisine, including daily specials and unique sides.

Carrie's Catering

Carrie's Catering is primarily a full-service catering company that earns recognition in the BBQ category for its expertise in providing delicious, customized food for large events. While the menu is customizable for occasions like weddings and corporate meetings, their inclusion here suggests that their BBQ offerings, such as pulled pork or smoked meats, are a highly requested and acclaimed part of their diverse catering menu, consistently satisfying large crowds across the Ohio Valley.

Izzy's Food Truck & Catering LLC

Izzy's Food Truck & Catering LLC is a versatile, mobile culinary business that brings high-quality food, including BBQ, to various locations and events. While the food truck menu features items like smash burgers and wraps, their catering service is known for high-end options that include Pulled Pork and Pork Tenderloin, demonstrating their skill with smoked meats. Founded by a culinary arts graduate, Izzy's is committed to serving the highest quality food in the valley, with their desserts, like homemade cheesecake, being a particular highlight.

Thanks, Gemini.