The 5 Best Bakeries Around Wheeling

There is little that rivals the comfort of warm bread or the joy of a perfectly decorated cake, and the bakeries of the Ohio Valley are the heart of this sweet pleasure. The Best of the Ohio Valley Readers' Choice 2025 recognizes these five establishments for their commitment to craft, flavor, and creating delightful experiences for the community.

Fat Apple Bakery

Fat Apple Bakery has made a name for itself through its extensive menu of both sweet and savory baked goods. The selection includes a classic array of pies, available whole or by the slice, such as fresh apple, cherry, and lemon meringue, alongside treats like cupcakes and pocket pies. Their bakery case often features breakfast pastries like cheese puffs and almond croissants, making it a reliable spot for morning treats or custom orders for special occasions.

Little Annie's Sweets

Little Annie's Sweets is a highly-rated, specialty dessert shop focused on creating expertly crafted treats. Customers often praise their delicious cakes and macarons, with reviews highlighting items like their tiramisu for being light and not overly sweet. This establishment is recognized for providing high-quality, reasonably priced desserts that make it a go-to place for families and individuals looking for a memorable sweet fix.

Sarah’s On Main

Sarah’s On Main operates as a popular Bakery and Cafe, offering a unique blend of baked goods, breakfast, and lunch items. While they offer classic bakery staples like morning buns and croissants, their signature item is the Salty Bread Breakfast Sandwich, which is consistently highlighted as a best-seller. They also prepare specialty items in-house, such as their savory quiches and homemade focaccia bread used for their lunch sandwiches, making it a versatile downtown favorite.

The Crumby Apron - Walker's Ice Cream

The Crumby Apron is a culinary spot that has expanded to offer more than just baked goods, combining the comfort of a bakery with a venue for food and events. Although the focus is not purely on sweets, their recognition highlights a menu that includes sub sandwiches and flatbreads, suggesting a diverse offering beyond simple pastries. They are also known for hosting community activities, reinforcing their role as a popular social and dining hub.

The Jakery

The Jakery is a Wheeling bakery recognized for its innovative and artisanal approach to baking. The practice emphasizes creativity and flavor, focusing on custom desserts perfect for events like office parties, weddings, or baby showers. By focusing on made-to-order creations, The Jakery demonstrates a dedication to quality ingredients and custom designs that make any celebration special.

Thanks, Gemini.